MLB Betting for Blue Jays Fans: Run Line, Totals and Starting Pitchers
By StakeReferralCode.ca Editorial Team · Updated
Baseball betting revolves around the moneyline (who wins), the run line (baseball's version of a spread, usually 1.5 runs) and the total (combined runs). What sets MLB apart from other sports is the starting pitcher. Odds are built around who's on the mound, and many sportsbooks let you choose whether your bet depends on the listed starters actually pitching. There are no picks or predictions here. Baseball has plenty of randomness, and no betting approach guarantees a profit.
Who can bet on MLB with Stake
Stake.com is not available in Ontario or Alberta. That's worth knowing for Blue Jays fans in Toronto and across Ontario. Stake's terms list Ontario as a prohibited jurisdiction, and using a VPN to get around that breaches them and can lead to frozen funds. Alberta now has its own regulated market, and the Stake.com offer on this site doesn't apply to Albertans.
In the other provinces and territories, Stake.com accepts players. It's licensed in Curaçao rather than by a province, which puts it in a legal grey area. Provincial lottery sites are the government-run alternative. Check Stake's terms and your province's rules before you deposit.
MLB basics that shape the odds
- 30 teams, each playing a 162-game regular season, followed by the postseason.
- Games are nine innings. If the home team is ahead after the top of the ninth, it doesn't bat in the bottom of the ninth.
- In regular-season extra innings, each half-inning starts with a runner placed on second base.
- The Blue Jays play home games at Rogers Centre, which has a retractable roof, so weather affects their home games less than at open-air parks.
The moneyline
The moneyline is the most common baseball bet: pick the winner, extra innings included. Because even strong teams lose regularly, prices are usually tighter than in basketball. You'll see both decimal odds and American odds (for example −150 or +130). Our guide on how to read betting odds covers converting between them.
The run line
The run line is almost always set at 1.5 runs:
- Favourite −1.5: must win by two or more runs.
- Underdog +1.5: covers if it wins outright or loses by exactly one run.
Why walk-offs matter
Here's a quirk that's easy to miss. When the home team takes the lead in the bottom of the ninth (or in extra innings), the game ends immediately. That often means a one-run win, even if the home team might have kept scoring. So a home favourite at −1.5 can win the game and still lose the run-line bet. A road favourite, by contrast, always gets to bat in the top of the ninth.
Totals (over/under)
A total is a bet on combined runs scored by both teams. Lines are often set on a half run (for example 8.5) so there's no push; whole-number totals can push.
Things that move MLB totals:
- Starting pitchers on both sides, and how deep they're expected to go.
- Ballpark and weather, including wind and temperature at open-air parks (and whether the roof is open at Rogers Centre).
- Lineup news, such as a regular getting a rest day.
Extra-inning runs count toward the full-game total on most books.
Starting pitchers and listed-pitcher rules
The starting pitcher has a bigger effect on a single baseball game than almost any individual player in other sports. Because of that, sportsbooks often handle pitcher changes in a special way. Common options include:
| Option | What it means if a starter changes |
|---|---|
| Action | The bet stands no matter who pitches, though the odds may be adjusted |
| Listed pitchers | The bet is void unless both named starters start |
| One listed pitcher | Only the named pitcher on your chosen side must start |
Not every book offers all of these, and the default can differ. Check the bet slip and the sportsbook's baseball rules before you confirm, especially if a pitcher's status is uncertain.
First five innings (F5)
First-five markets settle on the score after five innings. They are designed to focus on the starting pitchers, since starters usually work the early innings and bullpens decide the late ones. There are F5 moneylines, run lines and totals. If a game is shortened before five innings, these bets are usually void.
Worked example: a Blue Jays home game
Here's one game with illustrative numbers only, not real odds:
| Market | Selection | Decimal odds | Implied probability |
|---|---|---|---|
| Moneyline | Blue Jays | 1.70 | 58.8% |
| Moneyline | Opponent | 2.25 | 44.4% |
| Run line | Blue Jays −1.5 | 2.40 | 41.7% |
| Run line | Opponent +1.5 | 1.60 | 62.5% |
| Total | Over 8.5 | 1.91 | 52.4% |
| Total | Under 8.5 | 1.91 | 52.4% |
The Jays score in the bottom of the ninth to win 4–3. Here's how each bet settles:
- Blue Jays moneyline wins. A $20 bet returns $34.
- Blue Jays −1.5 loses. They won by one run, the walk-off ending the game before they could add more.
- Opponent +1.5 wins. A one-run loss is inside the cushion. A $20 bet returns $32.
- Under 8.5 wins. Seven runs in total.
The two moneyline probabilities add up to about 103.2%. The extra above 100% is the bookmaker's margin, which is why betting on the favourite every time doesn't guarantee a profit.
Rain delays and shortened games
Open-air games can be delayed, suspended or shortened by weather. Sportsbooks set rules for when a shortened game counts as official, and the rules can differ between markets (for example, totals and run lines often need the game to go the full distance). Read the baseball section of the sportsbook's rules so a rain-out doesn't surprise you.
Practical habits for Jays bettors
- Check the probable starters on the day, and decide whether you want listed-pitcher protection.
- Think about the long season. With 162 games, it's easy to bet too often. A fixed stake and a set budget help; see our bankroll management guide.
- Be careful in-game. Live baseball odds swing with every pitch and pitching change. Our live betting tips explain how to keep control.
- Keep fandom separate. Cheering for the Jays is half the fun. Just don't treat loyalty as an edge.
FAQ
What's the run line in baseball?
It's a 1.5-run handicap. The favourite must win by two or more; the underdog covers if it wins or loses by exactly one.
What happens to my bet if the starting pitcher changes?
It depends on the option you chose. "Action" bets stand (sometimes with adjusted odds); "listed pitcher" bets are usually voided if the named starter doesn't start. Rules vary by book.
What are first-five-inning bets?
Bets settled on the score after five innings. They focus on the starting pitchers and leave out most of the bullpen's work.
Conclusion
Moneyline, run line and totals cover most MLB betting, but the starting pitcher is what makes baseball different. Know your listed-pitcher option, understand why walk-offs often end in one-run games, and read the rules on shortened games. If you're in an eligible province and want to try Stake, register through the Claim button on this page and enter code SHIMA in the "Code (Optional)" field.
Related Guides
- Ready to sign up? Start with the Stake.com referral code (SHIMA).
- MLS Soccer Betting Canada: 1X2, Draw No Bet, Totals
- UFC Betting Guide: Moneylines, Method and Round Props
- Sports Betting Bankroll Management: Simple Rules
- All Stake guides for Canada
Play responsibly
Set a budget before you bet and use Stake's deposit limits, loss and wager limits, cooling-off and self-exclusion tools in your account settings. If betting stops being fun, free confidential help is available through your provincial helpline (for example, Quebec 1-800-461-0140 or New Brunswick 1-800-461-1234). See our responsible gambling page for every province's number and more support options.
19+ (18+ in AB, MB, QC). Not available in Ontario or Alberta. Gambling can be addictive – play responsibly.